The Andy Fastow Subtext…

by | Mar 4, 2010 | ECM Industry, eDiscovery, Records Management | 15 comments

File this under: “what the …”, “huh?!”, “is this ECM related…”, or “let’s bear with it for a bit, it may go somewhere…”.

So for those of you who may not have heard: The Andy Fastow Story is a far-fetched, weird and wonderful fantasy about a man who single-handedly (well almost…with a little help from a few close golfing buddies: Jeff, Ken, Michael, Rick, Ben and David, amongst others) brings down a giant company, nay, a whole industry, tailspins an entire country into recession, causes the loss of tens of thousands of job and billions of dollars of people’s savings, illegally bags tens of millions of dollars for himself and his best buddy Michael, etc… In this little tale, our hero Andy is magically transformed from an Ordinary Joe to Financial Genius with the help of his friend, and self-anointed god, Jeff. Andy then gets to make up “Andy’s World”, where everything is always wonderful for him and all bad things in the real world are shoved into a box called LJM and then a bigger box called LJM2 (and a couple of broken down pales called Chewco and Raptor). In Andy’s World, Andy and Michael get to make up all the rules. Everybody is invited to play in Andy’s World—at a fee. Everybody will win a participation prize. Everybody will lose a whole helluva lot. Errr, except for Andy and Michael of course—they always win. Until one day, when a nosy stranger starts asking questions like “Andy, how do you do it? …like, can you teach me how to stick really bad things into an ordinary box just like yours and have them just disappear and make me loads of money just like you?” Well, one thing leads to another and this nasty thing called the SEC starts poking and prodding Andy’s World, bugging Andy and asking him the same kinds of stuff; except this SEC thing is scary and has some gnarly militia working for it. The nerve of the SEC questioning whether Andy is on the up and up! Of course, just like all good fantasies, after a bout of the uglies (a little public humiliation and a few years outside the comfort of Andy’s World—chilling in an institution near Colorado), our hero rises at the end and gets to fight another day (presumably with some of those millions he bagged earlier). Unfortunately his friends, well except Michael again, didn’t do so well: poor Ken died, Ben and Rick went to jail, David became known as the world’s most infamous shredder, and Jeff was vilified around the world and got blamed for everything bad in Andy’s World. Oh, and, like millions of people’s lives’ got permanently messed up.

Pretty good story, eh?! I’ve even heard some rumors that it’s loosely based on real life

Dilbert on Enron

Of course the moral of the Andy Fastow Story is that we don’t want another Andy Fastow story. Actually, no more stories at all of that genre. Sadly, it seems to be a trite plot prone to repeat. Who can forget the Bernie Ebbers or the Dennis Kozlowski Story? Or the Lehman and AIG Show? Don’t even start with Maddof! So many copycats, it’s hard to keep track.

The answer to stop these stories, one presumes, is to put in place some controls. Tools that support the controls. And, a scary, ugly and expensive editing process affectionately called the threat of eDiscovery. Oh, and a whole bunch of government type people, lawyers, accountants, bankers and consultants. Now, surely there will never be another Andy Fastow Story. There will never be another Arthur Andersen willing to edit another Andy Fastow Story. In fact, we won’t even need to have any more authors or heroes for these kinds of stories. Our tools will auto-document happy stories where everyone wins and everyone is treated fairly. So, that’s where ECM comes in!

Unfortunately, it seems, again, that reality is just not complying with our carefully thought out plot. Dang! In spite of noise to the contrary, and HUGE vendor propaganda promoting the discovery of gold reincarnated in the all signing, all dancing eDiscovery products tied to ECM solutions, it seems there is a “fiction gap” between is and would-like to be. In fact, records management en-masse (which one would presume to be a precursor to eDiscovery products) is seemingly not much more than email archival these days. All this seems to point to the obvious. What’s the subtext here?

Perhaps the subtext is in the incentives and disincentives. eDiscovery, empirically, seems to be a dance. The goal really is not full discovery or going to court—that would be insanely expensive for most organizations—but a happy settlement, which would be less insanely expensive. Of course to get to the settlement, you still need some level of eDiscovery…to know what is insane and what is less insane! Now, what if eDiscovery were easier? ECM, records management, search and eDiscovery tools all working in unison. A nirvana to be sure. But, would that not potentially lead to greater exposure of being discovered? Would the disincentive of the lengthy, costly and archaic discovery process now be replaced with the incentive of protecting yourself through the same lengthy, costly and archaic discovery process?! Certainly the US government (through the FRCP; Federal Rules of Civil Procedure) doesn’t hope so. In fact, since the December 1, 2006 amendments to the FRCP, effectively dealing with eDiscovery is very much supposed to be on the legal and corporate roadmap of most organizations; moreover they have the burden of responsibility for adequately managing discoverable information at their own cost.

So, where does that leave us? In the spirit of Mr. Fastow and company, I suspect somewhere between pay now or pay later…which is to say, little evidence of much competence at this time. In my opinion, effective and somewhat efficient eDiscovery is directly tied to successful deployment of ECM—properly indexing, managing, storing, retrieving and archiving information, and a streamlined implementation of Records Management—identifying, classifying, retaining and disposing of formal records based on corporate and regulatory compliance policies. I’m sure the eDiscovery vendors would not entirely, or possibly at all, agree with some of these assertions. But then again they may have incentives not to…


Need a bit more info on how Armedia can help you?

Feel free to schedule a 30-minute no-obligations meeting.


  1. Quinton Sancrant

    Reports with regard to the prostate in every case concerned me. That actual story, The Andy Fastow Subtext… Armedia, offers techniques fantastically fascinating and simply abreast observations. Most definitely i’ll make my best pals learn with reference to this amazing report moreover mainly because it is about a bit of the creative concepts I already have held for a long time.

  2. Thailand Shop

    Fantastic article. There’s a lot of beneficial info here, though I did want to let you know something – I am working on Ubuntu with the up-to-date beta of Opera, and the design of your website is kind of bizarre for me. I can figure out the articles, but the navigation doesn’t function so solid.

  3. Locksmith Knoxville

    For whatever reason i’m ending up with a blank page whenever i try post a comment,do you recognize how its going on?i’m making use of oprea web-browser

  4. Shredder

    Reading this i finally took a break from this job. I have a hardware store, and i get kinda stress throughout the day =) this post just gave me a few minutes of relax =] I tried to find a rss feed on your site, so that i could subscribe for some more. Ill be sure to come here more often from now on ^__^

  5. lymph nodes

    Agreed on so many levels… Keep up the good Work!

  6. Dominic Troe

    Quite an informative post you have here! Subscribed! 😀

  7. Dont touch me

    Thanks buddy. Good site you got here. Have some more sites to point to with a bit more information?

  8. Bobby

    Great read. This will be my First time to your site. Greatful for sharing . I have to subscribe to this blog. I was a car repairman for years. Our repair tip of the century is this: Please don’t make an attempt a difficult work job by yourself. That will cost you mo money in the end. Thank you one more time….

  9. Lucila Slaton

    I think this is a real great post.Really looking forward to read more. Will read on…

  10. Lurline Moisey

    I absolutely must think much more in that course and find out a few things i can do over it.

  11. graphic design careers

    You actually wrote about many engaging things in this posting. I came across this by using Google and I’ve got to admit that I already subscribed for your site, it is very good (:


Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *